What You'll Find Here
Let me get straight to it: I think Berkshire Hathaway stock is one of the most misunderstood large caps out there. After personally holding it for over a decade and watching it survive recessions, scandals, and market manias, I can tell you it’s not a typical company. You’re buying a collection of businesses—from Geico to BNSF Railway—plus a massive equity portfolio managed by the world’s most famous investor. But that doesn’t mean it’s bulletproof.
Why Berkshire Isn’t Just a Stock
Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (tickers: BRK.A and BRK.B) is a holding company. That means when you buy a share, you own a tiny slice of dozens of wholly owned subsidiaries (think Dairy Queen, See’s Candies, Precision Castparts) plus a $300+ billion stock portfolio (Apple, Bank of America, Coca-Cola). It’s basically a diversified conglomerate with a built-in hedge fund.
I remember reading the annual letter for the first time and thinking, “This is not a normal CEO report.” Buffett writes like he’s talking to his neighbor. That transparency is rare. But it also means investors sometimes overlook the structural complexity. For example, Berkshire’s earnings are lumpy—insurance underwriting swings wildly, and the stock portfolio’s unrealized gains distort GAAP net income. Many newbies panic when they see a quarterly loss due to paper losses, not realizing operating earnings were actually fine.
The Warren Buffett Effect
Let’s be honest: the stock’s valuation has historically carried a “Buffett premium.” People trust him, so they pay more. But what happens when he’s gone? I’ve heard that question for 15 years, and it never goes away. The board has planned for succession—Greg Abel is the designated successor—but the market will likely react emotionally. I’ve personally seen dips of 5-8% when Buffett’s health rumors surface. That volatility is a feature, not a bug.
Yet the businesses themselves are strong. Geico’s cost advantage, BNSF’s rail monopoly, and Berkshire Hathaway Energy’s regulated utilities generate cash like clockwork. Even without Buffett’s capital allocation skills, the collection of moats should keep compounding. But the stock’s multiple may compress by 10-15% post-Buffett. That’s a risk you must accept.
How to Value Berkshire Hathaway
Forget P/E. Berkshire’s insurance float makes that metric misleading. I use price-to-book (P/B) and a sum-of-the-parts approach. Historically, Berkshire has traded between 1.2x and 1.6x book value. Currently (as of my last check), BRK.B is around 1.5x book—not cheap but not crazy.
Here’s a simplified sum-of-the-parts table I keep in my spreadsheet:
| Component | Estimated Value (per BRK.B share) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance (float + underwriting) | ~$90 | Float is a “free” loan; underwriting profits add |
| Railroad (BNSF) | ~$70 | Based on comparable railroad multiples |
| Utilities & Energy | ~$50 | Stable regulated earnings |
| Manufacturing, Service & Retailing | ~$80 | Diversified industrial profits |
| Stock portfolio | ~$160 | Market value of holdings (Apple alone ~$100) |
| Cash & T-bills | ~$40 | Record cash pile |
| Estimated total | ~$490 | Compare to current BRK.B price (~$410 as of writing) |
Notice the gap. That “Buffett discount” or “conglomerate discount” is normal. If you buy at $410, you’re getting $490+ of asset value. But the discount can widen during bear markets. I’ve seen it go to 20% below sum-of-parts. Patience is key.
BRK.B vs. SPY: Head-to-Head
I constantly compare Berkshire to an S&P 500 index fund. Over the past 10 years, BRK.B has roughly matched the S&P 500 total return (maybe a bit behind). But the ride is different. Berkshire is more defensive—it held up better in 2022 when growth stocks crashed. Its 5-year beta is around 0.75. That means less volatility, which I love as I get older.
Here’s a quick comparison table:
| Metric | BRK.B | SPY |
|---|---|---|
| 10-year annualized return | ~11.2% | ~12.5% |
| Max drawdown (2022) | -23% | -33% |
| Dividend yield | None | 1.4% |
| Expense ratio | 0% (if you don’t trade) | 0.09% |
If you need income, Berkshire won’t give it. But it reinvests all earnings internally—that’s effectively a forced savings plan. I prefer that for taxable accounts because I control when to realize gains.
Three Mistakes Investors Make
Mistake 1: Treating BRK.A and BRK.B as identical
BRK.A (the A share) trades around $600,000 and has voting rights; BRK.B is 1/1,500th of a Class A share, with limited voting power. For 99% of us, BRK.B is the better choice. But I’ve seen people buy BRK.A without realizing they could own 1,500 B shares for the same cost and get more flexibility for selling portions.
Mistake 2: Ignoring the float liability
New investors see the massive cash pile and think “lots of cash = safe.” But much of that cash is held against insurance claims (float). It’s not free money—if claims surge unexpectedly, Berkshire could need to draw down investments. That hasn’t happened in decades, but it’s a tail risk. I always check the combined ratio (underwriting profitability) to gauge health.
Mistake 3: Selling on Buffett’s death
I made this mistake early in my investing career. I sold BRK.B in 2010 when there was a health scare. Lost out on a 200% gain since. Buffett’s death will cause a short-term dip, but the underlying businesses will keep generating cash. Unless you need the money urgently, hold through the noise. The succession plan is solid.
FAQ
This article reflects my personal analysis and is not financial advice. Always do your own research.
Reader Comments